Thoughts on Week 2 and Strategy Tips (Mon 4/19/10)
Monday, April 19th, 2010Thoughts from Week 2
- Good start - Again, as I discussed last week, don’t get too excited by players’ early-season results, good or bad. If you truly believe that Alberto Callaspo & Jason Varitek will end the season with more home runs than Alex Rodriguez and Carlos Lee, then I’d like to sell you a non-refundable round-trip airline ticket to Iceland that has to be used in the next 48 hours.
- Bad start - Before you hit the “Drop” button and bail on a player this early in the season, ask yourself this: if this were July or August instead of April, and the player had been performing at their expected level, then suddenly had a 2-3 week “slump”, would you react the same way? The only difference between July/August and April is the amount of prior data available to smooth out the rough patches. If you wouldn’t dump the player if his slump occurred in July/August, then you shouldn’t dump him in April either. Yes, there may be more “talent” available on the waiver wire in April than in July/August, but if you preferred the player in question at the time of your draft/auction, then barring a serious injury or loss of a job, you should still prefer the player currently on your roster. If any of you drop Carlos Lee to pick up Eugenio Velez, you’ll be able to hear me scream from wherever you happen to be reading this.
- Keeping it real - Just in case you’re curious, here were my preseason projections for Ponce de Leon Jr (aka Livan Hernandez): 10 Games Started, 59 Innings Pitched, 3 Wins, 5.51 ERA, 1.60 WHIP, and 28 Strikeouts. I stand by that, and even though he may start more than 10 games for the Nationals, don’t be at all surprised if his ERA and WHIP approach those projected levels before he’s eventually released. Feel free to remind me if I’m wrong.
- Should I like Ike? - It appears that within the next few days Mets first baseman Ike Davis will be the first highly-touted prospect to be called up to The Show in 2010. While I give the Mets credit for belying their “Fred Coupon” reputation, I still don’t think this is a good idea from either the team’s or the player’s perspective. At least Davis has 10 AAA games under his belt, which is 10 more than fellow Mets rookie Jenrry Mejia had before he made the team this Spring. However, even though there have been cases where skipping/spending minimal time in AAA has worked (e.g. - Ryan Braun, Evan Longoria, and to a lesser extent, Matt Wieters come to mind), I’m generally not comfortable relying on rookies who’ve spent less than half a season at each level in the minors. For every Ryan Braun success story there must be at least a dozen cautionary tales like Fernando Martinez’. Sure, if you play in a keeper or dynasty league, go ahead and pick Davis up if you’ve got space on your roster. However, if your primary goal is to win this season and you’re in need of a first baseman, better to go with a proven commodity such as Aubrey Huff than to cast your fate to the wind. My projections for Mr. Ike: 256 AB (remember, Daniel Murphy will be back in early-mid May), .242 AVG, 6 HR, 31 RBI, 25 R, and 0 SB - not quite the stuff of legends, no?
- Closer roulette - After a year of relative calm on the closer front, it appears that things have returned to their normal state in 2010 (meaning that we can expect at least 10-12 teams to change closers at least once during the course of the season). Kevin Gregg is now in, Chad Qualls may be out, Kerry Wood & Brian Fuentes could be back as soon as this week, while Huston Street, Brad Lidge, & Mike Gonzalez don’t figure to rejoin our wacky world until sometime after May Day. Don’t discard Jason Frasor just yet if you already own him, and consider him a good speculative pick-up if he’s sitting in your free agent pool. Some other names to keep an eye on: Kevin Jepsen, Kam Mickolio, Jensen Lewis, Ryan Perry, Joel Zumaya, Cla Meredith, Daniel Bard, Mark Lowe, Sergio Romo, Peter Moylan, and Tyler Clippard. Finally, add A’s relievers Michael Wuertz and Joey Devine to your watch list when they come off the DL.
- The pool on the hill - If you’re lamenting your pitching staff’s early season performance (or lack thereof), some names that have caught my eye so far are Bud Norris, Tom Gorzelanny, Kevin Correia, Dana Eveland, Colby Lewis, and Luke Hochevar. If they’re all spoken for, some minor leaguers worth speculating on include Christian Friedrich, Jhoulys Chacin, Martin Perez, and Jeremy Hellickson.
- Well positioned - If you’re in need of some hitters, guys to keep an eye on include Nate Schierholtz, Seth Smith, Eric Hinske, J.R. Towles, Pedro Alvarez, Jeremy Hermida, Alex Gordon, Ty Wigginton, Pat Burrell, Carlos Santana, and Fred Lewis. In the unlikely event you’re playing in a league with Livan Hernandez’ relatives, see if you can trade them Livan straight up for Carlos Lee. No need to thank me for this advice.
Strategy Corner
- Crazy cats - If you play in a league that gives bonus points for no-hitters and you just happened to have Ubaldo Jimenez in your lineup last week, then congratulations. However, if you’re planning to trade for guys who can help you with no-hitters, perfect games, cycles, etc, don’t waste your time. Games that register points in these categories are so infrequent and so unpredictable that they’re virtually meaningless for use as fantasy baseball categories - you might as well throw all your league’s managers’ names in a hat, pick one at the end of the season, and randomly award them extra points. Sure, CC Sabathia, Tim Lincecum, Roy Halladay, Johan Santana, Chris Carpenter, Adam Wainwright, Zack Greinke, Dan Haren, & Felix Hernandez all have a better chance of throwing a no-hitter than Livan Hernandez or Jason Marquis, but so far, both groups of pitchers have the same total number of no-hitters in their collective careers, which is to say “none”.
- Stars and scrubs forever? - The “Stars & Scrubs” approach has long been a favorite roster-building technique for those playing in auction leagues. Load up on as many star players as you can afford, the thinking goes, and you’ll have such a big advantage over the competition that you can still win even if you sit on your hands for most of the auction, then swoop in at the end and buy the majority of the players on your roster for a dollar or two. All you need is one or two of your scrubs to have breakout seasons, and you’ll inevitably be perched atop your league’s standings when the season ends. While I understand the logic behind this approach (e.g. - the top performers should go for a hefty premium because of their relative year-to-year consistency), I heartily disagree with it, especially in “only” leagues. The point of auction leagues is to accumulate as much talent in aggregate as you can subject to your league’s constraints (e.g. - starting lineup salary, total team salary, roster requirements, etc.). Ideally, you’d like every player on your roster to produce at better than their expected level. However, when you pay a premium on the top players, you’re reducing your team’s chances of acquiring the most talent in aggregate. The key to success in most leagues is not the number of big names on your roster, but rather the aggregate number of innings pitched and at-bats your team racks up. In a mixed league it’s still relatively easy to wind up with everyday players at every position, but you’ll probably have at least a few Jack Wilsons and Carlos Silvas on your roster if you go this route. If you’ve adopted the Stars & Scrubs approach but see your team stuck deep in the standings, check the correlation between the number of at-bats and a team’s place in the standings - you’ll be surprised. If this describes your team, you may want to consider trading off several of your stars in exchange for 2 or 3 solid, reliable (if unspectacular) performers who face little to no competition for everyday at-bats.
Wrapping Up
- I’m writing a weekly entry this season for Fantasy Windup, which is USA Today’s fantasy baseball blog. Each week I list 8-9 players who should be on your radar screen if you need to make a roster adjustment for the following week; the entry will generally be posted late Sunday afternoon or early Sunday evening.
- I’m also contributing to a weekly entry called “Makers & Breakers” on Forbes.com’s Sports Money blog, which is edited by Zack O’Malley Greenburg. Each panelist suggests one widely available player who is likely to make a better-than-expected contribution to your team’s title chances, and one highly owned player who is likely to disappoint you and sabotage your team. This entry will generally be posted Wednesday afternoon or evening.
Enjoy today’s “Patriots’ Day Games”, and have a great week!
The Sherpa
The Fantasy Baseball Sherpa’s Blog
@fantasy_sherpa on Twitter
The Fantasy Baseball Sherpa’s Facebook fan page