So it’s finally happened. Jay Bruce, who is less than half Barack Obama’s age and less than one-third of John McCain’s age, but has seemingly generated more conversation in 2008 (at least among fantasy baseball enthusiasts) than Obama and McCain combined, has finally landed in Cincinnati.
Stripping away the hype, what does this mean for those with the foresight to stash Bruce at the beginning of the season or the waiver wire priority to claim him during the season? Will he make the immediate impact that rookies Ryan Braun and Hunter Pence did after the call-ups during the 2007 season? Will he disappoint the way that Alex Gordon did during his rookie season (also 2007)? Or, as the cliche goes, does the true answer lie somewhere in the middle?
Based on his minor league rate stats, with a few subjective adjustments, here’s what I think you can realistically expect from Bruce for the rest of this season:
- 409 AB
- 62 R
- 114 H
- 30 2B
- 5 3B
- 16 HR
- 68 RBI
- 12 SB
- 36 BB
- 115 SO
- .279 AVG
- .330 OBP
- .494 SLG
So, where would these results place Bruce among his more established peers? The Sherpa Point scale assigns a score of 1.00 to the player with the top score in each category; all other players’ scores in that category are based on their result in that category compared to the league leader’s. For example, if the league leader is projected to hit 50 HRs, a batter projected to hit 40 HRs would receive 0.80 Sherpa HR pts, a batter projected to hit 25 HRs would receive 0.50 Sherpa HR pts, etc. For average-based categories such as AVG, OBP, SLG, and OPS, a proxy statistic is used. Thus, if you play in a league that uses 5 offensive categories, the maximum Hitter’s Sherpa Points score would be 5.00.
Pro-rating my Preseason Projections for all Hitters, I project that in a league using the 5 standard offensive categories (AVG, HR, RBI, SB, and R) Bruce would score 2.38 Sherpa Points. This would place Bruce roughly 20th overall, comparable to the projected Sherpa Point scores for fellow Outfielders Chris Young and B.J. Upton. Obviously, their Sherpa Point scores will vary by category (in some cases quite a bit), but on an overall basis, that’s where I believe Bruce’s value will fall. For the sake of comparison, the Top 3 Outfielders (based on Preseason Projected Sherpa Points) were Matt Holliday (3.56), Carl Crawford (3.19), and Vlad Guerrero (3.08).
So while Bruce should be a strong contributor to your fantasy team if you’re fortunate enough to have him, he will not carry you to your league’s championship by himself. It wouldn’t surprise me at all if he’s eventually a Top 5 Outfielder from a fantasy perspective, but that’s highly unlikely to happen in 2008. As long as you temper your expectations, you will not be disappointed.
Until next time,
The Sherpa